
While water is vital for life on Earth, scientists have long assumed it’s also essential for life elsewhere. This belief has shaped decades of thinking about planetary habitability.
However, the factors that make a planet habitable may have little to do with water. In fact, life could potentially exist in environments where water is scarce, sustained by an entirely different type of liquid. According to a new MIT study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, one such candidate is an ionic liquid — a salt that remains liquid below about 100 °C.
In lab tests, researchers created ionic liquids by combining sulfuric acid with certain nitrogen-containing organic molecules. On rocky planets, sulfuric acid could result from volcanic activity, and nitrogen-based compounds — already found on asteroids and planets in our solar system — may also occur in other planetary systems. This suggests that such liquids could form naturally on worlds far different from Earth.
Potential for Life in Extreme, Waterless Environments
Ionic liquids have extremely low vapor pressure, meaning they don’t evaporate, and can exist at higher temperatures and lower pressures than liquid water can withstand. Researchers note that these fluids can provide a stable environment for certain biomolecules, such as proteins that remain intact within them.
The team suggests that even on planets too hot or with atmospheres too thin for liquid water, pockets of ionic liquid could still exist. And where liquid is present, there may be potential for life — though likely very different from Earth’s water-based organisms.
“We think of water as essential for life because it’s necessary for life on Earth,” says study lead Rachana Agrawal, a former MIT postdoc in Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences. “But if we broaden the definition, what’s truly required is a liquid that can support metabolism. Including ionic liquids in that definition could vastly expand the potential habitability zones for rocky planets.”
The MIT co-authors of the study include Sara Seager, Class of 1941 Professor of Planetary Sciences in the Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences, who also holds appointments in the Departments of Physics and Aeronautics and Astronautics, along with Iaroslav Iakubivskyi, Weston Buchanan, Ana Glidden, and Jingcheng Huang. Other contributors are Maxwell Seager from Worcester Polytechnic Institute, William Bains from Cardiff University, and Janusz Petkowski from Wroclaw University of Science and Technology in Poland.
A Fluid Breakthrough
The team’s exploration of ionic liquids began as part of their search for potential life on Venus, a planet shrouded in thick, toxic clouds of sulfuric acid. While harsh, these clouds could still harbor traces of life — an idea that upcoming atmospheric missions aim to investigate.
Agrawal and Seager, who leads the Morning Star Missions to Venus, were studying methods to collect and evaporate sulfuric acid. Any samples brought back from Venus’ clouds would need the acid removed to detect leftover organic compounds that might indicate life.
Using a custom low-pressure setup designed to evaporate excess sulfuric acid, they tested a mixture of the acid and the organic molecule glycine. In every trial, most of the sulfuric acid boiled away, but a persistent layer of liquid remained. They discovered that sulfuric acid was chemically reacting with glycine, transferring hydrogen atoms to it. This reaction produced a salt-based fluid — an ionic liquid — that stayed liquid under a wide range of temperatures and pressures.
This unexpected discovery sparked a new question: Could ionic liquids naturally form on planets that are too hot and have atmospheres too thin for water to survive?
“From there, we began imagining the possibilities,” Agrawal says. “On Earth, volcanoes produce sulfuric acid, and organic compounds have been detected on asteroids and other planetary bodies. That made us wonder whether ionic liquids might also form and persist on exoplanets.”
Stony Havens
On Earth, ionic liquids are mostly created for industrial applications and rarely occur naturally — with the sole known exception being a case where they form from the interaction of venoms produced by two competing ant species.
The researchers aimed to determine the natural conditions under which ionic liquids could form, as well as the temperature and pressure ranges in which they could persist. In lab experiments, they combined sulfuric acid with various nitrogen-based organic compounds. Previous studies by Seager’s team showed that sulfuric acid can unexpectedly preserve some of these compounds, which link to life’s chemistry.
“In high school, you learn that acids like to give up protons,” Seager explains. “From our earlier work with sulfuric acid (the primary component of Venus’ clouds) and nitrogen-based compounds, we also knew that nitrogen tends to take up hydrogen. It’s a bit like one person’s trash becoming another’s treasure.”
Ionic Liquids Form Easily Under Diverse Conditions
The researchers discovered that a small amount of ionic liquid could form when sulfuric acid and nitrogen-based organics were mixed in a one-to-one ratio — a proportion not examined in earlier studies. For this new work, Seager and Agrawal combined sulfuric acid with more than 30 different nitrogen-containing organic compounds under various temperatures and pressures, then evaporated the sulfuric acid from the mixtures to see if ionic liquid remained. They also tested the reaction directly on basalt rocks, which are common on the surfaces of many rocky planets.
“We were amazed by how often the ionic liquid formed,” Seager says. “When we placed sulfuric acid and the organic compound on rock, the extra acid seeped into the pores, but a droplet of ionic liquid still remained on the surface. No matter what we tried, it kept forming.”
Ionic Liquids Can Form in Extreme Heat and Low Pressure
The experiments showed that ionic liquid could form at temperatures as high as 180 °C and under very low pressures — far below Earth’s atmospheric pressure. These findings indicate that, given the right conditions, ionic liquids could naturally arise on planets where liquid water cannot survive.
“We imagine a planet hotter than Earth, without water, that at some point — past or present — contained sulfuric acid from volcanic outgassing,” Seager says. “That acid would need to come into contact with a small patch of organic material, and organic deposits are quite common throughout the solar system.”
She explains that the resulting pools of liquid could persist on the planet’s surface for years or even millennia, potentially acting as tiny refuges for simple forms of life based on ionic liquids. Seager’s team now plans to explore what biomolecules and other life-related ingredients could survive — and possibly flourish — in such environments.
Read the original article on: MIT
Read more: Severe Alert for the U.S. as Hurricane ‘Traffic Jams’ Become Ten Times More Likely














